Say You Love Satan presented by About Face Theatre at The Greenhouse Theater Center

Chicago Tribune - Not Recommended

"...Aguirre-Sacasa offers a potpourri of cliched characters, self-referential smarts, hackneyed pop culture references and a plot that drowns in its own inconsistent rules."

Chicago Reader - Somewhat Recommended

"...the offbeat premise is squandered in glib cliches (think Will & Grace meets The Omen), and the horror-movie spoofing trivializes the pretensions to philosophical allegory (light and life vs. darkness and death). Crisp comic performances draw laughs in About Face Theatre's production, directed by Scott Ferguson; especially good work comes from Scott Duff as a Truman Capote-esque angel and Elizabeth Ledo as the hero's sardonic confidant."

Windy City Times - Somewhat Recommended

"...It’s a thin but engaging work in the manner of the old gay sitcom Brothers, but minus the relentless machine gun of one-line laughs. Rather, Say You Love Satan borrows from the early Durang-Inaurato satire, The Idiots Karamazov, using Fyodor Dostoevsky’s dialogue between good and evil as a framing device. Not a lotta laughs in Dostoevsky."

Gay Chicago Magazine - Highly Recommended

"...Just in time for the Halloween season, About Face Theatre offers up this delightful sacrifice to the Prince of Darkness by way of a hysterical romp in the hay with Rosemary’s Baby. I love Satan. There, I said it. I mean, I love “Say You Love Satan.” I love a good horror story, especially around Halloween. I also love a good laugh. And this Chicago premiere offers a tempting helping of both."

Time Out Chicago - Recommended

"...Great comic performances, however (Elizabeth Ledo as Andrew’s bitter best friend, multi-roled Scott Duff) and the flashy lighting and sound design (by Christopher Ash and Joshua Horvath, respectively) encourage us to sit back and enjoy the pop culture."

ChicagoCritic - Somewhat Recommended

"...Say You Love Satan is mediocre and that’s my problem with it. Better to stretch than play safe. The younger gay crowd will either laugh hardily or be offended by this show. Too bad because the premise has potential. Some may enjoy this show, I found way too predictable and threadbare."