Chicago Tribune
- Highly Recommended
"...Over the course of about two intermission-less hours (although it feels much shorter), these characters bash away at each other and at themselves on the inevitable human quest for happiness. In the end, you see they are not as different from their progressive counterparts as they think."
Chicago Sun Times
- Somewhat Recommended
"...The play premiered off-Broadway in 2019, so the multitude of Steve Bannon references make sense considering when the script was likely written. Watching the production now, the same week Democrats demolished Trump-backed Republicans in the midterms, not only make the production feel dated, but unfairly comical. It's impossible to watch these conservative characters without an air of snark as they question such weighty issues as abortion and trans rights, all the while treating the culture wars as an actual impending blood-drawing Civil War. The audience knows what will actually unfold. A lot."
Chicago Reader
- Highly Recommended
"...Seeing Will Arbery's Heroes of the Fourth Turning at A Red Orchid Theatre the same weekend as Erik Gernand's Year One provided an interesting study in contrasts and parallels. Where Gernand's play depicts one provincial family in 1933 Germany wrestling with the rise of Hitler, Arbery's 2019 play puts us closer to our own time, after the first election of Donald Trump. But instead of a family of nice middle-class people finding out how ill-equipped they are to face fascism, the characters in Arbery's play, at least on the surface, are the victors in the culture wars."
Chicago Theatre Review
- Highly Recommended
"...Will Arbery's unique 2019 play, HEROES OF THE FOURTH TURNING, premiered Off-Broadway and garnered high critical praise and lots of accolades. It was a 2020 finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in Drama, as well. Called "a red-state unicorn" by The New York Times, Arbery's play explores characters in transition filled with ultraconservative viewpoints and ideas, an unusual quality in today's theatre. Beautifully directed with a steady fierceness by dado (director of A Red Orchid's VEAL and SIX MEN DRESSED LIKE JOSEPH STALIN), this production is heavy with learned ideas and political theories. With superb technical support by scenic designer Grant Sabin, lighting designer Josiah Croegaert and original music and sound designer Ethan Korvne, as well a gifted cast of actors, visit HEROES OF THE FOURTH TURNING ready to lean forward and engage your mind. Because one thing is certain: As a theatergoer you cannot look away."
Buzz Center Stage
- Highly Recommended
"...Settling in for A Red Orchid Theatre's Heroes of the Fourth Turning, I knew next to nothing, having no familiarity with the playwright Will Arbery. Partly by design, I avoid preconceived notions and try to listen to the play itself, and watch the performers as I review. Even with so-called "canon" plays like Chekov or Miller."
The Fourth Walsh
- Recommended
"...Four graduates of a conservative Catholic college return to their alma mater to celebrate a favorite professor being named President. Their reunion is a booze soaked existential crisis. Justin wrestles with the sins of his past. Emily is tortured by physical and emotional maladies.Teresa is a virtuoso of sanctimonious fervor. And Kevin spirals between becoming a priest or getting a girlfriend. In school, they united over an unwavering adherence to their faith and their teacher. In the real world, their rigid belief system has them on shaky ground. They are either digging their heels in deeper and/or seeking asylum in drink or denial."
Third Coast Review
- Recommended
"...Will Arbery's 2019 Pulitzer Prize-finalist drama Heroes of the Fourth Turning might also be called the Four Horsemen of the Trumpocalypse, each communicating different end-times scenarios, or perhaps the four directions of conservatism as revealed on the rundown front porch and around the front yard firepit of an older graduate at a remote Wyoming Catholic college. Ensemble member dado directs this Chicago premiere."
PicksInSix
- Recommended
"...The current production of Will Arbery's challenging “Heroes of the Fourth Turning” at A Red Orchid Theatre through December 6 offers ideas that are hateful and difficult to hear, let alone accept, and just plain wrong to a large number of people. Some might consider its subject matter quite anachronistic after the results of the midterm elections. It's not an easy play to watch and absorb. But as with the catalogue of thoughtful presentations at A Red Orchid Theatre over the years, it indeed makes you think—maybe too much, but hey, that's naturally contained in, as the saying goes, the 'belly of the beast' for Mr. Arbery—and in the end to many, it's good theatre."
Werner's Theatre Reviews
- Recommended
"...After leaving A Red Orchid Theatre's Chicago premiere of Heroes of the Fourth Turning, it is difficult not to reflect on how little has changed since the play first premiered in 2019. What was once a timely examination of political and generational divides feels just as relevant today, if not more so."
NewCity Chicago
- Highly Recommended
"...The characters in "Heroes of the Fourth Turning," now getting its Chicago premiere at A Red Orchid Theatre, certainly imagine that they're good Christians. They're trying with all their might. But their efforts are baffled by their own fears and desires, and result in pain instead of charity."