Chicago Tribune
- Somewhat Recommended
"...Gershman’s performance is certainly worth seeing if you’re a fan of King’s music. She captures King’s unembellished tone and homey Brooklyn twang with a relaxed stage presence that makes her seem like someone you could get coffee with. And if you’re patient, you’ll hear “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman” and “I Feel the Earth Move” — so don’t leave before curtain call is over."
Daily Herald
- Somewhat Recommended
"...From the audience’s response, enthusiasm for King and her music remains undiminished. No surprise there, not for a show whose not-so-secret weapon is its endlessly appealing score. It primarily consists of classics by King and her first husband, lyricist Gerry Goffin, plus a handful of tunes by fellow songwriters and friendly competitors Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil along with songs from several other composer/lyricists. The book is by Douglas McGrath."
Let's Play Theatrical Reviews
- Highly Recommended
"...This captivating play, Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, is a feel-good story and an exceptional musical that holds a special place in my heart. Remember, I started by telling you I was biased. The music, the story, and the performances are all brilliantly crafted, leaving a lasting impression on anyone who experiences it. The show's ability to evoke emotions, from joy to sadness, is unparalleled. It truly is a masterpiece!""
Around The Town Chicago
- Highly Recommended
"...This musical with a book by Douglas McGrath and words and music by the characters that bring the story to life is an amazing biography of Carole King ( played to perfection by Samantha Gershman, who is new to Drury Lane’s stage, but pay heed Chicago, she will be around for years to come). Gershman is terrific and played well with the cast of players thta make up an ensemble that is top-notch."
Chicago Theatre Review
- Highly Recommended
"...Drury Lane’s production is a joyous and magical musical, from start to finish. No one will leave the theatre wishing for more because Jane Lanier’s polished production leaves it all on the stage. Starring the very best actor/singer/dancers, featuring gorgeous, much beloved songs from the past and creating a deserved tribute to one of America’s finest musical artists, this Must-See musical is quite simply “Some Kind of Wonderful!”"
Buzz Center Stage
- Highly Recommended
"...Samantha Gershman is AMAZING and offers an enthralling portrayal of Carole King in her Drury Lane debut. With a perfect blend of vulnerability and incredible strength, Gershman captures the essence of the iconic singer-songwriter, bringing her inspiring journey to life with genuine warmth and exceptional talent. Gershman, fantastic throughout, really showcases her King-like vocals and magnetic charisma in a climactic concert scene, delivering a powerful performance of the title track "Beautiful.""
Chicagoland Musical Theatre
- Recommended
"...Drury Lane's go at "Beautiful" is the latest production of the Carole King bio-musical in Chicagoland after both Marriott and Paramount had their turn. It's understandable if the discerning theatergoer feels somewhat fatigued, but there's more than enough going on in Oakbrook Terrace to recommend theirs as more than just easy listening."
PicksInSix
- Highly Recommended
"...Directed by Jane Lanier with musical director Carolyn Brady and choreographer Gerry McIntyre, "Beautiful" is an inspiring story, and a delightful behind-the-scenes look at how the music industry worked back when performers often did not write their own songs. While the plot lacks the depth to really explore the relational complexities of Carole's young life in particular, there is such fun in learning about the origin stories of so many beloved songs. Plus, the talented cast elevates the musical with strong vocal performances throughout."
Splash Magazine
- Highly Recommended
"...Drury Lane Theatre’s production of “Beautiful: The Carole King Musical” is a resounding triumph, offering audiences an unforgettable journey through the life and music of an iconic American artist. Running from January 29 to March 23, 2025, this jukebox musical captures the essence of Carole King’s rise to stardom with both heart and authenticity."
BroadwayWorld
- Highly Recommended
"...This is a great story about a woman who followed her dreams. The core four were instrumental in creating some of the greatest music tracks ever recorded. Sadly, Cynthia Weil passed June 1, 2023. Gerry passed in 2014. Carole and Barry are friends to this day. They share a birthday as well. Carole had some very rough spots along the way but ultimately great success. She knew the journey would require help. That’s where family and friends come in. Sit back, listen to the soundtrack of our life and enjoy the journey. Drury Lane Theatre provides the vehicle. It’s a great ride."
